4 Comments

Sardar K.B.S. Sidhu, an esteemed former IAS officer, has shared insights on the intricate dynamics between the Governor and the Chief Minister of Punjab. Initially, one might feel a tad disheartened by the tone of their interactions, especially considering our rich democratic traditions and values.

After a thoughtful analysis, it becomes clear that both parties have their perspectives, which merit consideration. Yet, the manner in which these viewpoints are exchanged could perhaps be more in line with the grace expected of constitutional institutions. There's an element of zeal, possibly influenced by political ties in New Delhi. While passionate discourse is essential for democracy, it's equally vital to preserve the dignity of such august offices.

It would be heartening if someone of stature, perhaps like the Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, could gently remind both parties of the values and standards their positions inherently demand. There had been constrained relations between Presidents and prime ministers but to this extent.

Mr. Sidhu's article was an enlightening read, balancing the nuances of the situation adeptly. We hope and kindly request Mr. Sidhu to continue sharing such objective and timely pieces on a diverse range of topics. His insights are much appreciated.

Expand full comment
author

Grateful for your generous appreciation— and, of course, very insightful appraisal.

Expand full comment

Sardar K.B.S. Sidhu, an esteemed former IAS officer, has shared insights on the intricate dynamics between the Governor and the Chief Minister of Punjab. Initially, one might feel a tad disheartened by the tone of their interactions, especially considering our rich democratic traditions and values.

After a thoughtful analysis, it becomes clear that both parties have their perspectives, which merit consideration. Yet, the manner in which these viewpoints are exchanged could perhaps be more in line with the grace expected of constitutional institutions. There's an element of zeal, possibly influenced by political ties in New Delhi. While passionate discourse is essential for democracy, it's equally vital to preserve the dignity of such august offices.

It would be heartening if someone of stature, perhaps like the Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, could gently remind both parties of the values and standards their positions inherently demand. There had been constrained relations between Presidents and prime ministers but to this extent.

Mr. Sidhu's article was an enlightening read, balancing the nuances of the situation adeptly. We hope and kindly request Mr. Sidhu to continue sharing such objective and timely pieces on a diverse range of topics. His insights are much appreciated.

Expand full comment

Sardar K.B.S. Sidhu, an esteemed former IAS officer, has shared insights on the intricate dynamics between the Governor and the Chief Minister of Punjab. Initially, one might feel a tad disheartened by the tone of their interactions, especially considering our rich democratic traditions and values.

After a thoughtful analysis, it becomes clear that both parties have their perspectives, which merit consideration. Yet, the manner in which these viewpoints are exchanged could perhaps be more in line with the grace expected of constitutional institutions. There's an element of zeal, possibly influenced by political ties in New Delhi. While passionate discourse is essential for democracy, it's equally vital to preserve the dignity of such august offices.

It would be heartening if someone of stature, perhaps like the Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, could gently remind both parties of the values and standards their positions inherently demand. There had been constrained relations between Presidents and prime ministers but to this extent.

Mr. Sidhu's article was an enlightening read, balancing the nuances of the situation adeptly. We hope and kindly request Mr. Sidhu to continue sharing such objective and timely pieces on a diverse range of topics. His insights are much appreciated.

Expand full comment