Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brig. K Singh (retd)'s avatar

It’s not that we don’t have visionary, erudite people like Lt Col (US Army Reserve) Shyam Sankar in India - as similar people go abroad and are instrumental for innovative technologies and programs there. The problem is the system here.

I served in the DRDO for five years; as the first Director (Intelligence Coordination) of the Defence Intelligence Agency (DIA), I helped raised the DIA as per the recommendations of the KRC; later, I served for a decade in the National Security Council Sectt. as the Head of Defence & Defence Intelligence; and post-retirement in the NDMA/MHA .

My take on the systemic issues:-

-most superiors are from that pre-Industrial Revolution 3.0 (Digital) era, where STEM was limited to knowledge of Pythagoras Theorem, NACL+H2SO4, and Newton’s Third Law; and the most difficult subject was English - one was confronted with essays ranging from The Thirsty Crow to My Best Friend to My Father to My First Airplane Ride to I attended a Hockey-Match, etc, and understanding of Wren & Martin. Even today, many bureaucrats are from St. Stephens. Thus, most had the latest Apple desktop open on their side-table – but didn’t know what to do with it and were prone to working thru’ dictation to a smart PA /PS.

-yet, each one thought that he/she knew everything about everything - and if you tried to explain anything, they would either interject with inanities (which took the discussion to an entirely different direction), or they cut you off as they were fearful you might think they are unaware of that issue.

-now contrast this with the presentation to us about how Saddam Hussain was captured – the visiting 3-star US General introduced the issue and then calmly handed over the floor to a Master Sergeant for the presentation – which made all our people very uncomfortable (“a three-stripper telling us...?”). There was absolutely no cognizing that people lower down the hierarchy can specialize and be experts in their fields.

-next: while we have many thinkers, there are very few who can take a problem, break it down into its component parts, find a workable solution / program / methodology for each, and then then implement the entire the sub-programs individually such that they are one large synergistic, workable whole. Just look at the simple Swachch Bharat Mission and the open defection eradication program - they made crores of toilets, but forgot to cater for water to flush those t toilets and to manage the resultant waste. That's stupidity at an elemental level.

-we are prioritize rhetoric and spectacle over substance, with almost every official more focused on his own image, his CR, his promotion and postings. The end result is that both peers and superiors will not hesitate to put you down if they feel you POV overshadows them in any way. I was often told that if I wanted an idea to be tossed up the hierarchy, then I must ensure that my boss gets all the credit. Worse - most of our politicians are not well educated and officials, instead of siding with an idea which is good for the deptt / country, will side with the political leader(s) in order to curry favour.

In the 19th Century, Mark Twain had rightly observed that "a person with a new idea is a crank until the idea succeeds". That still holds good here in the 21st century. Add that a person with an idea is actually prey for the vultures who don’t get the same spotlight.

Thoughtful India's avatar

This comment is a complement to Big. Singh’s comment. While he’s talked from an establishment perspective, I’ll give an industry pov.

————-

Defence tech had for long been a taboo in Silicon Valley.

Big Tech proactively eschewed military contracts due to internal employee pressure.

Over the last 5 years, there has obviously been a “vibe shift”.

The Indian tech eco-system is too beholden to American intellectual fashions and usually operates at a lag.

You’ll start to see a lot of “defence” and nationalist tech companies. It’s happening already.

However, the problem is fashions change. If in three years, Trump is gone and pacifist liberals have regained their cachet you’ll see a vibe shift again.

But while America would have built up their Andurils of the world by then, the fledgling Indian startups would be caught flat footed.

There needs to be independent thinking champions in India’s tech ecosystem to nurture these companies and shield them from ephemeral political/market trends.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?