Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Madan Rattan's avatar

Sir:

I grew up admiring Bhagat Singh and Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose. Their defiance, idealism, and love for the country left a deep imprint on us from a young age. So much so, that I once spent my meager pocket money to buy wooden-carved portraits of both from a street hawkerโ€”portraits I still treasure.

But alongside admiration, there has also been a lingering sense of sadness and resentmentโ€”especially around the silence that surrounded Bhagat Singhโ€™s execution. I have often wondered why Mahatma Gandhi did not make a stronger plea to the British to commute the death sentence to life imprisonment. Even if it had failed, a gesture of solidarity might have resonated differently through history.

Another thought that has stayed with me is the subtle injustice meted out to Bhagat Singhโ€™s two compatriotsโ€”Rajguru and Sukhdev Thapar. These three brave hearts stood shoulder to shoulder in their mission and ultimately shared the same gallows. Yet, over time, Rajguru and Sukhdevโ€™s stories have faded into the background, overshadowed by the towering legacy of Bhagat Singh. It is not that their sacrifice was any lessโ€”it was equal in action, spirit, and consequence. But public memory has a way of being selective.

There are moving accounts of Bhagat Singhโ€™s last meetings with his family, his composed defiance in the face of deathโ€”but we hear little, if anything, of Rajguru or Sukhdev in those final moments. Their absence in the larger narrative feels like a quiet omissionโ€”an enigma that history has not yet addressed.

I hope someday, we give them their due. That their names, their courage, and their stories are remembered not as supporting chapters, but as integral parts of the same epic.

Perhaps, one day, a postscript will be writtenโ€”one that echoes not just Bhagat Singh, but Rajguru and Sukhdev too, in full and equal measure .

Thank you

Expand full comment
Sandeep Kumar Verma's avatar

Main message of Shahid Bhagat Singh is missing from this long article.

Bhagat Singh was advised by the Britishers to apply for mercy petition but he refused to do so.

It is because he wanted to send a message to people of India that freedom for me is greater than my life and it should be so for every young boy involved in the freedom struggle.

He said that I am assured that our country going to become free from clutches of Britishers but the mental slavery people suffer due to Caste will take long time and much tougher struggle.

So his message will continue to be shared by the people of India to next generation till Indians will get their second freedom from Black Indian English people ie Upper caste Hindus after annihilation Caste.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts